The two lawsuits

Heller v. Hyler: two verified civil actions in the Mendocino County Superior Court against Vincent Michael Hyler, Judith Hyler and Michael Hyler.

No. 26CV04599: for taking J.J. and keeping him

CourtSuperior Court of California, County of Mendocino
FiledOctober 15, 2026
DefendantsVincent Michael Hyler; Judith Hyler; Michael Hyler (named as Doe 1, October 27, 2026)
ClaimAbduction and withholding of a child from a parent entitled to custody (Civil Code § 49, subd. (a)), with punitive damages for malice and oppression
StatusAll three defendants served. Pending.

The complaint sets out what the court record shows. The February 11, 2026 order gave Carli Heller sole physical custody of J.J. and let him live with her in Florida. It has never been vacated, stayed or modified by any written order. The temporary order Vincent Hyler obtained without notice on August 12 expired by its own terms at the September 2 hearing, and the minutes record no extension. He took J.J. from her home in Florida on August 19 on a paper that did not permit taking him out of the state. His own declaration puts J.J. at a clinic in Ukiah at 1:00 p.m. on August 26, the day before any order allowed travel to California.

On September 26, Vincent Hyler and Judith Hyler each signed for written notice that her custody order had been registered in Florida. They have kept J.J. from her since. Asked in writing on August 22 where her son was, they have never answered. The complaint alleges that the defendants agreed to keep J.J. from his mother and acted together to do it, with knowledge of the only custody order in force, and concealed where he was.

No. 26CV04707: for the abuse, and for helping it

CourtSuperior Court of California, County of Mendocino
FiledNovember 9, 2026. Verified, 89 paragraphs, jury trial demanded
DefendantsVincent Michael Hyler; Judith Hyler, also known as Judy Hyler; Michael Hyler, also known as Mike Hyler
Claims(1) Domestic violence (Civil Code § 1708.6), against Vincent Hyler. (2) Aiding and abetting domestic violence, against Judith Hyler and Michael Hyler. Punitive damages for malice and oppression.
StatusAccepted for filing; summons issued; service under way.

J.J. was made sick before he was born by the man who now holds him. The complaint sets out the abuse Carli Heller lived under through the pregnancy, every day: physical and sexual abuse, threats, food and sleep withheld, drunk driving with her as his passenger, and four days abandoned without a car, food, water or money right after a hospitalization. Her blood pressure reached levels that put her in the hospital at least twice, and J.J. was induced two weeks early as a direct result. He has been diagnosed with Sensory Processing Disorder and retained primitive reflexes, which the clinician who evaluated him in June 2026 attributes to his exposure to domestic violence before birth.

It quotes the March 15, 2025 recording, made the day she told him she would seek a restraining order: “The paperwork’s filed. … And I’m goin’ full custody.” “My family’s got money too.” “I’m not done breaking you yet.” Two days later he filed for custody. It sets out what Judith and Michael Hyler knew and did. Michael Hyler paid the bar tabs for the drinking during which the abuse happened. Judith Hyler told her not to call the police and kept handing J.J. to him knowing he drove drunk with him. Both answered her pleas for help by blaming her. J.J.’s own claim for what was done to him before he was born is reserved, to be brought on his behalf.

The papers

The amendment naming Michael Hyler is in the document library. Both complaints, in full, are with the court file on the records page. Public copies will be posted here once J.J.’s birth date and the house address are redacted from them.

Also pending against them: sanctions motions against both of Vincent Hyler’s lawyers, Kali Perkins in Mendocino (No. 25FL01030) and Carrington Mead in Lee County (No. 26-DR-005826). Every filing is on the filings page.