The lawyer’s own records

On the afternoon of November 17, 2026, Kali S. Perkins, Vincent Hyler’s lawyer, filed 458 pages under oath in the Mendocino County Superior Court to collect $33,818.85 from Carli Heller. Pages 166 to 180 are her office’s billing, entry by entry, by date and by the tenth of an hour. They record what her office did with the Lee County deputy who took J.J., with the Mendocino District Attorney’s investigator, and with two sheriff’s offices, in the weeks before Carli Heller was arrested.

How it came to be written down

Ms. Perkins’s request that the court make Carli Heller pay Vincent Hyler’s legal fees was served on October 27, 2026. The same day, Carli Heller served a sanctions motion identifying five statements in that request that had no evidence behind them, which started a twenty-one-day clock under California law. On the last day of that clock, Ms. Perkins filed an amended request: a 13-page memorandum and a 458-page declaration, sworn to by her, with an itemized schedule of every hour her office says it spent (Exhibit M). Eleven entries in the schedule are redacted for privilege. The entries below are not.

About an hour before the amended papers arrived, Carli Heller had written to Ms. Perkins that she was preparing a federal civil-rights action and that Ms. Perkins’s records of her office’s contacts with the Lee County deputy, the Mendocino investigator and the sheriff’s offices were evidence in it, and were to be preserved. The records were then filed, unredacted, in a public court file.

The entries, as sworn

Quoted as written, with the entry number from Exhibit M. “KSP” is Ms. Perkins; “AS,” “AL” and “JG” are her staff; “OPP” is Carli Heller; “MCSO” is the Mendocino County Sheriff’s Office; “sdt” is a subpoena.

DateEntryText
Aug. 2688“Drafting remote appearance notice and proposed order for officer Brian Aigner.”
Aug. 2696“Calls with Lee County Sherriffs office, court liason, captain on duty and records department regarding officer appearance and providing the police report from August 19 at the 9/2 hearing.” (1.2 hours)
Aug. 26103“Prepare sdt for officer appearance and document production of report.”
Aug. 26Cost 7“Process Serving: Subpoena to Lee County Sheriff Office for Deputy appearance — $225.00”
Aug. 27110“Provide remote appearance instructions to officer In FL for TECO hearing. P/C with court liason re the same.”
Aug. 31137“Email to deputy re: appt for prep ahead of hearing.”
Sept. 1140“Call with Officer for preparation before hearings. Call with KP re the same.” (0.9 hours)
Sept. 3151“phn call with investigator Mariano from MCSO re: heller report of kidnap” (Ms. Perkins personally)
Sept. 8157“check in w/ client via portal re status, discuss addl false police report made and calls” (Ms. Perkins personally)
Sept. 15169“status of police report docs for sanctions motion” (Ms. Perkins personally)
Sept. 18175“Emails with team re incident reports and access them for motion.”
Sept. 21176“Drafting request for police records for UPD re welfare check/ police showing up at clients house”
Sept. 22178“review sdt for officer for personal app and fu comm w/ PFL team re: addl sdts for out of state officers at hearing” (Ms. Perkins personally)
Sept. 22180“Sending records request to Mendocino County Sheriffs Office for incident report/ wellness check.”
Sept. 22182“Discuss witnesses with KP. call to officer re additional appearance.”
Sept. 29194“Phone call with DA Guzman, following up with clients message regarding 2nd welfare check with Lt. Chapman. Guzman confirming he will reach out to Sheriff’s office, and spoke about a restraining order against Heller. No criminal charges for false reporting against Heller.”
Sept. 30199“comm w/ client and team re: harassment by OPP re: welfare checks and request for fu w/ Guzman re: same” (Ms. Perkins personally)
Oct. 1205, 206“fu comm re: comm w/ DA and sheriff’s office”; “review comm w/ DA office re: same, and her filings” (Ms. Perkins personally)
Oct. 6253, 254“receipt and review of incident report from police”; “Following up with sherif department incident reports, submitting pra request.”

What was happening on those dates

On August 19, 2026, Lee County deputies took J.J. from his mother’s home in Bonita Springs on a Florida paper that forbade, in its paragraph 8, removing him from the state. The reporting deputy was Brian Aigner. By 1:00 p.m. on August 26, by Vincent Hyler’s own exhibit, J.J. was at a clinic in Ukiah, California, a day before any order allowed travel. That is the day Ms. Perkins’s office began calling the Lee County Sheriff’s Office about Deputy Aigner, drafted his appearance papers, and paid $225 to subpoena him as Vincent Hyler’s witness. He was prepared by telephone on September 1.

On September 2, the temporary order Vincent Hyler had obtained without notice expired by its own terms; the minutes record no extension. Carli Heller’s request to be told where her son was: denied. On September 7, a Mendocino County Sheriff’s deputy took her report (No. 2026-16870) of a child kept from the parent who holds the only custody order in force. On September 8, the District Attorney’s investigator, Mariano Guzman, told her by telephone that the other side had already spoken with him, that “the father has custody,” and that “all you’re doing is every day writing stuff to file in court.” Ms. Perkins’s entry for that day calls her report an “addl false police report.”

On September 11, at about one in the morning, Deputy Aigner, the deputy her office had subpoenaed and prepared, came to Carli Heller’s door on her missing-child report and told her J.J. “won’t be entered into the system.” Between September 15 and 23, Ms. Perkins’s office gathered police records about her “for sanctions motion.” On September 28, Lt. Chapman of the Mendocino County Sheriff’s Office, badge 1302, told her the Sheriff was “taking the same position as the District Attorney’s Office,” and that a recorded death threat and an unsurrendered firearm were “things that happened in the past.” At 5:31 p.m. that day she sent sworn criminal complaints against Vincent and Judith Hyler to two prosecutors, and at 5:32 p.m. a firearm referral to the ATF.

The next day, September 29, Ms. Perkins’s office spoke with Investigator Guzman about a restraining order against Carli Heller and about criminal charges against her, and he undertook to “reach out to Sheriff’s office.” That evening she was arrested at her home by Lee County deputies. Deputy Aigner was the one at her door. The day after, Ms. Perkins’s own entry calls her welfare-check requests “harassment by OPP.”

The heading, and the exhibit that isn’t there

Ms. Perkins’s memorandum presents these hours under a heading that says they were law-enforcement contacts “Following Ms. Heller’s Reports.” The earliest report her memorandum names is the one behind the September 3 call from the Sheriff’s investigator. The entries begin on August 26, eight days earlier, on the day J.J. was already in Ukiah, with her office subpoenaing the deputy who had taken him. The memorandum cites the incident reports about Carli Heller as “Exhibit GG.” The amended declaration’s exhibits run from A to FF. There is no Exhibit GG. The reports that would show what she actually told law enforcement were not filed.

The word she chose

In June 2026, at a hearing in the Mendocino case at which Carli Heller was represented by counsel, Ms. Perkins called her a kidnapper, six times, for living with J.J. in Florida, where the February 11, 2026 order expressly permitted her to live. Three months later, when J.J. had in fact been taken out of Florida against a Florida court order and his mother reported it, Ms. Perkins’s office recorded the reports as “false police report[s]” and set about collecting police records to use against her. On September 29 her office’s own entry records the answer from the District Attorney’s investigator: “No criminal charges for false reporting against Heller.” Carli Heller was arrested that night on a different theory. The State of Florida declined to prosecute it on October 26.

The arrest

Deputy Aigner presented the September 29 visit as a welfare check. He said the deputies were “here to exonerate you,” and asked for her Twitter handle. On that she let three deputies into her home and her bedroom. She was then put in a locked patrol car for about two and a half hours, in the cold, before an investigator arrived and said it was not a welfare check; held one to two more hours at the Sheriff’s investigations building in the middle of the night; made to unlock her telephone; and booked. She is immunocompromised. She was kept for days in a cell so cold that she was freezing throughout. At first appearance her bail was the highest in the room, though she has no record of any kind and had harmed no one. Her parents paid it. Had they not been able to, she would have remained in that cell until at least November 2. She was released with a GPS ankle monitor, which stayed on after the State declined to charge her. The Lee County Sheriff’s Office still has her telephone. Her dogs were taken to the county shelter; getting them back cost about $600. The arrest was on local television the next day.

What has been filed because of it

Opposition, No. 25FL01030Filed and served on Ms. Perkins’s office in the early hours of November 18, 2026 (envelope 25935775), with five exhibits. It quotes her entries by number, identifies the missing Exhibit GG, and asks the court to deny the fee request.
Heller v. Hyler et al., U.S. District Court, Middle District of Florida, Fort Myers DivisionVerified complaint, 43 pages, filed November 19, 2026, Case No. 2:26-cv-3119-KCD-NPM. Four counts under 42 U.S.C. § 1983: deprivation of custody and of the parent–child relationship without due process; conspiracy; conditions of confinement; and the Sheriff’s liability for his office’s customs. Defendants: Vincent Hyler; Judith Hyler; Michael Hyler; Kali S. Perkins, individually; Perkins Family Law, PC; Deputy Brian Aigner; Investigator Mariano Guzman; Lt. Chapman, badge 1302; Sheriff Carmine Marceno in his official capacity; and Does 1–10. Claims arising from the entry, arrest and prosecution of September 29–30 are reserved until the Sheriff’s Office produces its records of that night. Damages and a jury trial. All nine summonses issued November 19, 2026. The federal case
U.S. Department of Justice, Civil Rights DivisionComplaint No. 852678-SDR, supplemented with Exhibit M, the September 29 entry, the written preservation notice, and the arrest. Also sent to the FBI, Tampa Field Office.
Sanctions, No. 25FL01030Two motions against Ms. Perkins under Code of Civil Procedure § 128.7: the first on the firearm statement in the August 12, 2026 application, the second on the fee request itself. Pending.

Ms. Perkins’s amended declaration and memorandum are in the Mendocino County Superior Court’s file in No. 25FL01030, a public record. The opposition and the federal complaint are being added to the document library. Every filing is on the filings page.

The February 11, 2026 order of the Mendocino County Superior Court, the only custody order in force, gives Carli Heller sole physical custody of J.J. and lets him live with her in Florida. It has never been vacated, stayed or modified in writing by any court. It was registered in Lee County on September 22, 2026, and became final there on October 16, 2026. J.J. has been kept from his mother since August 19, 2026.